2025/26 Taught Postgraduate Module Catalogue

IDEA5366M Distributive Justice and Scarce Medical Resources (Online)

15 Credits Class Size: 30

Module manager: Sean Sinclair
Email: S.C.Sinclair@leeds.ac.uk

Taught: Semester 1 May to 31 July View Timetable

Year running 2025/26

This module is not approved as an Elective

Module summary

This module explores issues concerning the fair allocation of resources in health care. The module examines some central views about the just/fair allocation of benefits and burdens in society, and their implications for the just/fair allocation of health care.

Objectives

The aims of this module are, firstly for you to gain an understanding of some of the philosophical and ethical issues and arguments within healthcare allocation and their implications for health policy. Secondly, you will develop critical awareness of the ethical rationales underlying current approaches to central concepts in healthcare allocation and health policy.

These aims will be achieved through:

- Independent online learning where you will be introduced to core concepts, readings, and arguments and are encouraged to read texts critically and reflect on and analyse these arguments and concepts.
- Online discussion forums and synchronous webinars where you will have the opportunity to develop your own arguments on the topics and test these through critical reflection with other learners and academic staff.

Learning outcomes

On successful completion of the module you will have demonstrated the following learning outcomes relevant to the subject:

1- Critically evaluate different theories of justice and equality and their implications for rights of access to health care
2- Critically evaluate different criteria for prioritising patients and types of treatments
3- Develop your own views on the just distribution of healthcare through insightful and sophisticated argument

Skills Learning Outcomes

On successful completion of the module you will have demonstrated the following skills learning outcomes:

4- Communicate ideas and understanding clearly and concisely, using appropriate academic language (Academic and Work Ready skill)
5- Critically analyse source material and demonstrate independence of thought (Academic and Work Ready skill)
6- Independently search for and utilise appropriate material to support knowledge and analysis of topics (Academic, Work Ready, Digital and Sustainability skill)
7- Effectively communicate, participate and collaborate in an online environment (Digital and Work Ready skill)

Syllabus

Examples of possible topics:

- Justice And Equality
- Rawls and welfare liberalism
- Nozick and libertarianism
- Personal responsibility
- Ageism
- Rights To Health Care
- Needs And Luxuries
- Rationing And QALY's
- Public health and what we owe each other

Teaching Methods

Delivery type Number Length hours Student hours
On-line Learning 8 2 16
WEBINAR 1 1 1
Independent online learning hours 33
Private study hours 100
Total Contact hours 17
Total hours (100hr per 10 credits) 150

Opportunities for Formative Feedback

In addition to the formative feedback available to students in student hours and seminar-based activities, each student is invited to complete ONE piece of formative work which will receive written feedback.

Students are given a choice of: essay plan; exposition of an argument; objection and reply.

To ensure that students get the formative feedback that they need, they are asked to read and reflect on (i) the feedback they received in previous summative assessments, (ii) the PRHS marking criteria and (iii) the specific guidance provided on the summative assessment in this module. This requires students to critically engage with previous feedback, current expectations, and play an active role in honing their knowledge and skill development.

Methods of Assessment

Coursework
Assessment type Notes % of formal assessment
Coursework Essay 90
Coursework Contributions to online discussion 10
Total percentage (Assessment Coursework) 100

The resit for the discussion contributions will be an essay demonstrating familiarity with a wide range of debates and will be descriptively as opposed to analytically focused.

Reading List

The reading list is available from the Library website

Last updated: 03/03/2025

Errors, omissions, failed links etc should be notified to the Catalogue Team